Monday 17 February 2014

Tax on e-cigarettes, what will governments do?

On Saturday I wrote about one smokers wanting to save money, and ended up saving their own life: http://goo.gl/7uEsgy. In conclusion better health and better personal economy is two long term effects of vaping that we can be sure of. But as you can see this is about the personal economy of the individual, but what about the country's economy? The country will loose a lot of tax income if people stop smoking, but will the money they save on health care for these smokers make up for the loss? This article, http://goo.gl/PF23lw, discusses that issue in the UK and US, and it shows that the US would benefit economically if everyone stopped smoking while in the UK the effect would be the opposite.

The Norwegian Directorate of Health published some numbers on this in 2011: http://goo.gl/h7yfqr (the compete report can be found here: http://goo.gl/VzlUTI). The annual income from tobacco taxes was 8 billion NOK (100NOK is around £10), but the annual cost estimates related to tobacco smoking varies from 8 billion to 80 billion depending on how you calculate this. In the lowest estimate only health care costs and production losses due to sickness and early death is considered, while in the higher estimates they also take into account the value of lost life years and reduced quality life years. The report also estimates that the reduction in tobacco smoking we have had in the last 20 years here in Norway represents savings of around 25 billion NOK annually. Further reduction would give savings on around 2-3 billion NOK per percentage point. So here in Norway we are not dependent on the tax income from tobacco. However I doubt this is something that Norwegian politicians have thought about. The percentage of cigarettes smoked in Norway that was actually bought in Norway is sinking towards 50% (http://www.nettavisen.no/2826504.html), which means the tax income could be a lot more. The reason for this is of course that the taxes on tobacco is really high... so actually the politicians may have put us in this position unintentionally?

I totally agree with what Karl Erik Lund said in the interview I posted here in the beginning of January; the ethical side of this of course needs to be the basis of a reasonable health policy. He says such calculations are absurd in this matter, but I think they have some relevance anyway. The reason, as shown in the article I mentioned in the beginning, is that some countries have actually made themselves dependent on the tax income from tobacco. This is definitely not good. As we have seen above, this should not be the case in the US and Norway as these countries will benefit economically from this, but in the UK it becomes a problem. Their government has already made the mistake and the money has to be taken from somewhere. So something has to be done about this, and taxing e-cigarettes would be as unethical in the UK as it would be in the US and Norway. So it is important that the UK government is aware of this and take measures to turn the situation around NOW so that they are not depending on tax income from tobacco before it's to late. These calculations should have been done long time ago, because making one self dependent on such "sin-taxes" will always lead to economical problems eventually. The UK government, if they don't act quickly, will end up in a very difficult situation: One option is to place taxes on a product that will save millions of lives, and they will have a hard time explaining that to the public. Another option would be to increase other taxes, meaning the whole public (not only smokers) would have to pay for their earlier mistake. I wonder how they are going to solve this one... and if they are able to correct, and learn from, their mistake. I don't think it's impossible, but they do need to be aware of these numbers to fix it. And they do need to keep the ethics their to top priority to avoid getting into trouble again. Explaining why you place taxes on a life-taking product is easy, doing the same on a life-saving product is a totally different ball game.

19 comments :

  1. Thank you. The links are going to be useful. Well said

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maybe taxing those soft drinks and fast foods along with raising the taxes on real tobacco could suffice. Ha! Or perhaps a little less "Nanny State-ism" is the answer. As you and I are well aware, taxing healthy choices is a grave error (no pun intended). Thanks for the link Vaping Giraffe

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice bit of writing. I hold out no hope for the UK Gubbinsment having a metric milligram of...1/. Common sense and 2/. Common decency.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Did you know you can shorten your links with LinkShrink and receive $$$$ from every visit to your shortened links.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow such an amazing content keep it up looking forward for more on this website check this discounted coupon 2nd wife vape coupon

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow such an amazing content i never read this before keep it up and keep sharing with us more useful information. Check this dr crimmy coupons now and avail it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for sharing this amazing blog with some unique information keep it up. Here is dr crimmy coupons available for you avail it now

    ReplyDelete
  9. I check your blog regularly and attempt to take in something from your blog. Much thanks to you and sitting tight for your new post. Fed up of completing your online courses? Need someone’s help to complete your online course? If that is the case feel free to contact us because we can complete your entire course for you no matter what the subject is. Exam Help Online

    ReplyDelete
  10. This blog raises an important discussion about government taxation on e-cigarettes. As the industry evolves, it's crucial for policymakers to find a balanced approach. By the way, if you're looking to save on your automotive needs, don't miss the opportunity to grab the "https://usepromos.com/promo-codes/40-off-advance-auto-coupons" available at the provided link. Keep up the insightful content!

    ReplyDelete
  11. With our CC Clarke coupons, you can join the CC Clarke beauty revolution and save a tonne of money! Discover a wide variety of products that will enable you to bring out your inner beauty, from vital skincare products to must-have makeup items.
    https://justamazingdiscounts.com/brand/cc-clarke-coupons/

    ReplyDelete
  12. The consistent route and efficient substance make it simple to investigate and draw in with your posts. Book Uber cab using promo code, offers and save on every cab booking. Users get the latest coupons, exclusive bank offers and wallet cashback on booking Uber cab. No matter what city you are in or where you intend to go, Uber is ready to take you there. Use an Uber Promo Code 50 and travel within your budget so you can spend more on the things you love!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks For sharing this amazing blog. Get free Coupons and Discount codes with Brands Savings. The coupon code you'll find here is a door to your cash saving shopping binges, as well as keeping you on financial plan. Brands Reserve funds is prepared to favor you with such alluring investment funds that it's difficult to stand up to.

    ReplyDelete

  14. The imposition of taxes on e-cigarettes is a complex and multifaceted issue that governments around the world are grappling with.promocodestudio On one hand, there is a growing concern about the health risks associated with vaping, especially among young people.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The imposition of taxes on e-cigarettes raises thought-provoking questions about government policy and public health. On one hand, viewfreescore cancel membership it may be seen as a potential revenue source for governments

    ReplyDelete
  16. Appreciation for sharing this astonishing site. Welcome to SuperShopperHub, your one-stop objective for the latest movement codes, coupon codes, voucher codes, and markdown codes for various brands. We're revolved around giving you the best shopping experience by filling in as an augmentation among you and tremendous entryways for save holds. We aggregate and update codes reliably, reassuring you never miss a groundbreaking system.

    ReplyDelete
  17. <a href='https://www.brandssavings.com/promotions/">Brands Savings</a> is a website page that is based on giving you limits to make your electronic buying experience financial game plan sincere. We are focused on creating prospects and skylines by giving huge coupon codes from famous brands and retailers. Attempt to check in with us dependably so you miss no approaches or offers!

    The coupon code you'll find here is a way to your cash saving shopping gorges, as well as keeping you on money related game plan. Brands Hold saves is prepared to lean toward you with such beguiling endeavor funds that it's difficult to stand up to.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Appreciation For sharing this dazing site. Here is new accessible More rebate with Arrangement retailer, Coupon Codes, Voucher Codes and Coupons. for uniqne rebate just with: Super Savers Info

    ReplyDelete
  19. Appreciation for sharing this astounding internet based diary. Discharge happiness with STARPETS PROMO CODE! Ruin your fluffy mates with specific cutoff points on premium pet things and enhancements. Lift their fulfillment and success with StarPets. Grab your code for speculation finances that make tails influence and mumbles more awesome!

    ReplyDelete